Modernity and the Holocaust

“Reduced, like all other objects of bureaucratic management, to pure, quality-free measurements, human objects lose their distinctiveness.”

In 1989, Jewish Polish-British sociologist Zygmunt Bauman published a book called Modernity and the Holocaust, from which the lines above are taken.

In his book, Bauman shows how the Holocaust was a direct product of the modern bureaucratic society in which we live. He breaks down the components of what makes modern bureaucracies so efficient, the price of that efficiency, which is largely the loss of human qualities and distinctiveness, and the mechanization and instrumentalization of subjects, turning them into nameless, emotionless and distant objects. 

Bauman’s book certainly adds to the rich tapestry of possible explanations for the horrific, industrial extermination of the Jews of Europe. Like many other explanations, it fails to give an absolute cause or reason, but it adds an important component.

In spite of Bauman clearly tying the loss of human dignity to modernity, our tradition warns of the exact same process hundreds of years before there were cubicles in offices, spreadsheets and charts. And that warning directly connects to our Torah portion this week, Vayera.

Vayera is packed with iconic stories such as, the destruction of Sodom and Gemorrah, the negotiation of Abraham with God over the prophesied destruction, the banishing of Hagar and Ishmael, and most importantly, the Akedah—the command to Abraham by God to sacrifice his son Isaac.

However, the portion opens with a less grim and more positive story—that of Abraham and Sarah’s generous hospitality to the three strangers who pass by their tent, and the prophecy announcing that Sarah will give birth to Isaac.

The name of the portion, Vayera (and He was seen), describes how God appeared to Abraham at the very moment the three strangers approached his tent.

The Talmud in Bava Metzia brings us an interesting sugya.  

“There was an incident involving Rabbi Yoḥanan ben Matya, who said to his son: Go out and hire laborers for us. His son went, hired them, and pledged to provide sustenance for them as a term of their employment, without specifying the details.

And when he came back to his father and reported what he had done, Rabbi Yoḥanan ben Matya said to him: My son, even if you were to prepare a feast for them like that of King Solomon in his time, you would not have fulfilled your obligation to them, as they are the descendants of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob.”

The message here is fascinating.

When the son comes back and tells his father that he did not specify what meal or compensation the laborers will receive, the father sends him back to do so, saying: “My son, even if you were to prepare a feast for them like that of King Solomon in his time, you would not have fulfilled your obligation to them.”

Later in the Gemara (I Kings 4:22–23), our sages specify the exact offering in King Solomon’s feast: “And Solomon’s provision for one day was thirty measures of fine flour, and sixty measures of meal; ten fat oxen, and twenty oxen out of the pastures, and a hundred sheep, beside harts, and gazelles, and roebucks, and fatted fowl.” 

Anyone would agree that this illustrates the massive scale of food required for a royal court rather than the amount offered for laborers. Still, the father here tells his son that even a feast such as this would never fulfill the son’s obligation to the laborers.

This is curious because there are specific employment laws which the father insists the son must offer to the laborers, and he asks his son to clarify the terms according to these laws, which are “only a meal of bread and legumes.”

Now we may wonder, if even King Solomon's feast doesn’t fulfill the obligation to the laborers, then why would a meal of only bread and legumes?

The answer is at the end of the father’s words: “as they are the descendants of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob.”

Our sages conclude that Abraham’s hospitality in our portion was greater than any of King Solomon’s feasts, and that is because he saw the complete humanity in three strangers whom he had never met. 

What the father is trying to teach his son is that even though the law has a clear measurement of food a worker should receive per day, there is no measurement of human dignity or worth. We should consider every human being worth much more than the feasts of kings, and that even that would not fulfill our obligation to them.

The Talmud warns us to separate the monetary value we assign to different people in our society as part of a bureaucratic system, from the actual worth of human beings, which is limitless.

If we do not separate the two, if the numbers become people and the people numbers, those numbers may end up being tattooed on the arms of those who lost all worth or value in the eyes of others.

Bauman writes:

“Standing by the fence of Auschwitz, looking at these emaciated skeletons with shrunken skin and hollowed eyes—who could believe that these were really people? “These pictures, however, represent only an extreme manifestation of a tendency which may be discovered in all bureaucracies, however benign and innocuous the tasks in which they are currently engaged. I suggest that the discussion of the dehumanizing tendency, rather than being focused on its most sensational and vile, but fortunately uncommon, manifestations, ought to concentrate on the more universal, and for this reason potentially more dangerous, manifestations.”

Previous
Previous

What Life Should Mean to You

Next
Next

AI and Jewish Knowledge